Member of the Month

abjectwoe
May, 2025

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

Morality of hooking up with a bro's sister

profile picture
AmateurPilgrim
Posts: 286 - Karma: 2,667
Been good friends with this guy for about 3 years now, ski with him about every day in the winter and am at his house a lot and see his 2 year younger sister that is fairly good looking/good body and more or less up for anything. In a hypothetical ( future ) situation where his sister would come onto me would a hook up be ok?
POLL
Edit Poll
Votes:

Take care when editing a poll; Options should be similar to maintain vote integrity.

More options will be added automatically as you type. You must supply a question and at least two options. No HTML is allowed.

10 years ago
157 40
profile picture
HamFaceGirl
Posts: 5242 - Karma: 2,683
Hell ya
Do him too
LOL HAMFACE BACK BITCHES
10 years ago
10 7
profile picture
S.J.W
Posts: 7609 - Karma: 31,172
Don't do it dude, no good comes out of banging your friends sister.
10 years ago
5 3
profile picture
crotchvent
Posts: 1527 - Karma: 2,185
It depends on the guy. Some would be cool with it some would not. Have you ever made jokes about his sister being hot? How did he respond?
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
CHORIZO
Posts: 2003 - Karma: 10,039
Only read the title. Thats incest. Thats your sister. Pee in her butt.
10 years ago
16 1
profile picture
TOAST.
Posts: 7749 - Karma: 39,656
Why would you want to hook up with your sister?
10 years ago
14 1
profile picture
numnuts
Posts: 395 - Karma: 1,155
wincest for him? three way for you?
10 years ago
1 0
profile picture
skierman
Posts: 8600 - Karma: 9,518
Friendships eventually end but the memory of banging barely legal hot tang lasts forever.





Go for it and then describe getting in her pants to your buddy. Don't tell him its his sister and see if he high fives you.
10 years ago
38 0
profile picture
AmateurPilgrim
Posts: 286 - Karma: 2,667
crotchventIt depends on the guy. Some would be cool with it some would not. Have you ever made jokes about his sister being hot? How did he respond?


usually with fists and sassy comments
10 years ago
1 0
profile picture
K-Dot.
Posts: 3790 - Karma: 8,348
needs pics for a fair evaluation
10 years ago
11 0
profile picture
crotchvent
Posts: 1527 - Karma: 2,185
AmateurPilgrimusually with fists and sassy comments


That could be a bad sign.
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
Mingg
Posts: 14047 - Karma: 50,909
hahahahaha this happened with my older brother and sister. My brother was pisseddddd and never talked to the dude again after he beat the shit out of him.

I feel like if you have to ask this question you realize it is at least a little wrong but I mean, you do you man haha.
10 years ago
1 9
profile picture
PeppermillReno
Posts: 4884 - Karma: -719
Look. There is nothing wrong with being balls deep in your home boys sister. Nothing. If you think there is I suggest considering being transgender and getting into guys.


What there is something wrong with is bragging about it and rubbing it in. So if you are a man and can keep your fucking mouth shut get on that. If not realize you are too much of a bitch to bang her and keep quiet and don't bother.



Reference Ming's post about someone who did something like this and should have not let anyone know about it. Remember your friend is probably a virgin and has that hot piece of ass walking around his house half naked every day and since its his sis he can't hit it so he doesn't want his friends tapping what he can't have.



This is some nice no strings attached booty you can get a girlfriend and still bang this chick on the side without her causing problems appreciate it for what it is.
10 years ago
0 7
profile picture
PeppermillReno
Posts: 4884 - Karma: -719
Bang the mom while you are at it so he can't turn your friends against you if he finds out.. If you fuck his mom too he'll be terrified that word will hit the street and he'll have to accept it and remain your pal even if he hates you.

GL!
10 years ago
5 0
profile picture
Mar-O
Posts: 960 - Karma: 827
Honestly I would be pissed and probably would not talk to you again, so I would say no its probably not worth it if you want to stay friends with the brother..
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
KillaSeason
Posts: 3495 - Karma: 1,774
skiermanFriendships eventually end but the memory of banging barely legal hot tang lasts forever.





Go for it and then describe getting in her pants to your buddy. Don't tell him its his sister and see if he high fives you.


this is the best advice you will get. fucking send it son
10 years ago
2 0
profile picture
KillaSeason
Posts: 3495 - Karma: 1,774
skiermanFriendships eventually end but the memory of banging barely legal hot tang lasts forever.





Go for it and then describe getting in her pants to your buddy. Don't tell him its his sister and see if he high fives you.


this is the best advice you will get. fucking send it son
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
KillaSeason
Posts: 3495 - Karma: 1,774
skiermanFriendships eventually end but the memory of banging barely legal hot tang lasts forever.





Go for it and then describe getting in her pants to your buddy. Don't tell him its his sister and see if he high fives you.


this is the best advice you will get. fucking send it son
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
Lonely
Posts: 7112 - Karma: 68,912
PeppermillRenoBang the mom while you are at it so he can't turn your friends against you if he finds out.. If you fuck his mom too he'll be terrified that word will hit the street and he'll have to accept it and remain your pal even if he hates you.

GL!


Op, I can confirm from experience that this is the best advice. It really works.
10 years ago
1 0
profile picture
-benedetto
Posts: 5238 - Karma: 1,359
Obviously, it really depends on the friend and their relationship. And your relationship with the dude. Are you going to bang her and then only chill with him for her? Because then he might feel funny about that. You're going to get feelings for her and then when she's out fucking other dudes, your left sad and alone.

BTW, how old are you?
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
DanielPlainview
Posts: 391 - Karma: 1,707
ya one of my best friends did that, except he tried to date my sister as well as dig her out. After about a month my sister stopped talking to him. Now he doesnt have a best friend or my sister. Dont do it.
10 years ago
8 0
profile picture
Snowgoner
Posts: 5047 - Karma: 969
yes its fine, just tell or ask him first (depending on how much you really care about how he feels)
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
Stadtski
Posts: 972 - Karma: 3,349
I stayed at my friends condo for new years and when I was blackout drunk I guess I was sitting on the couch and my friends sister came in and fucked me. no lie. another friend walked in on us and took a snapchat of it and showed my friend who's sister it was. he wasn't even that mad at me though, mostly just at his sister because she was sober. and yes. technically she raped me.
10 years ago
2 1
profile picture
Kazabazua
Posts: 3529 - Karma: 1,128
I'd talk to him about it first. I dated one of my best friends older sisters for a while in secret (more her idea than mine) and always felt really bad about lying to my friend - probably one of the biggest mistakes I've ever made actually. We used to hang out a lot together (the 3 of us) but when things got serious between her and I, he definitely knew something was up (it gets hard to hide your feelings when you fall in love with someone). I could tell he was pissed about it so I ended up growing distant from her, unfortunately.

Moral of the story is, don't lie to your friends - you will feel like a giant piece of shit for it, even if it's for a pretty girl.
10 years ago
1 0
profile picture
Matthew-
Posts: 101 - Karma: 247
OP won't follow throw, just another fantasy story
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
PeppermillReno
Posts: 4884 - Karma: -719
KazabazuaI'd talk to him about it first. I dated one of my best friends older sisters for a while in secret (more her idea than mine) and always felt really bad about lying to my friend - probably one of the biggest mistakes I've ever made actually. We used to hang out a lot together (the 3 of us) but when things got serious between her and I, he definitely knew something was up (it gets hard to hide your feelings when you fall in love with someone). I could tell he was pissed about it so I ended up growing distant from her, unfortunately.

Moral of the story is, don't lie to your friends - you will feel like a giant piece of shit for it, even if it's for a pretty girl.


No you dweeb that isn't it at all its keep that shit quiet why the fuck did you date your friends sister instead of tapping it on the hush hush? You selfish fuck wanting a relationship with your friends sister you could have gotten pussy and maintained your friendship but you had to rub it and let people know you had a GF (that you didn't work for an obvious lay up of course) didn't you?


Forbidden fruit is always the sweetest. I'll give an example of one of my booty calls who I enjoy 10x as much as normal because she can't tell anyone since Im far more forbidden fruit than she is to me but I don't want my neighbor ever knowing I bang this lady either though I could tell my friends she can't tell hers. My next door neighbor is in her 50s and not quite hot enough for me to fuck. But one of her best friends who I met chilling at an upscale bar around from my house is shes pretty dime for being close to 60. This lady just got left by her husband for another woman and has a son my age and will likely soon be friends with my mom since my mom does whatever the fuck she wants and wants to move to near my house despite my mom having a beach house and a house in the west suburbs it isn't enough for my mom she wants her permanent home to be near the ocean like mine friggen 5 minutes away from me no more buffer zone. There's no stopping her. Anyways this lady can't possibly tell anyone about me and when she comes over once or twice a month parks 2 blocks away and wears a hoodie and makes me look out for my next door neighbor entering my house. The sneaking around makes it sort of awesome even though neither of us is cheating on anyone.

I'd be a total creep if I let my next door neighbor find out that Im tapping that since Im not interested in her (she looks fine for her age and is close to my standards but mine are high for cougars) it woud be the same thing as letting a close friend know I was fucking his sister.
10 years ago
1 5
profile picture
.lencon
Posts: 6753 - Karma: 17,197
My friend (who's a girl) hooked me up with her little sister who's now my gf. So I guess it's my homegirls sister. If girls are fine with it guys should be.
10 years ago
1 1
profile picture
Titus69
Posts: 9332 - Karma: 17,963
I dated my friends sister last year. We aren't close friends but he was fine with it. Nothing even happened, horrible relationship overall. If your friends cool with it have fun.
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
gnar_whal
Posts: 1286 - Karma: 3,788
.lenconMy friend (who's a girl) hooked me up with her little sister who's now my gf. So I guess it's my homegirls sister. If girls are fine with it guys should be.


double the pu$$y?
10 years ago
3 0
profile picture
Mr.noodle
Posts: 1361 - Karma: 4,655
I once fucked my friend, it made shit kinda awkward and he couldn't sit for the next 2 days. Over all it was a pretty good experience so I'd go for it
10 years ago
2 1
profile picture
PoLaRpEaK
Posts: 439 - Karma: 555
As long as your not an asshole and treat her well should be no issue.
10 years ago
2 0
profile picture
kim_jong_ill
Posts: 1019 - Karma: 3,147
I banged my buddy's twin sister so I have to say yes!
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
*DUMBCAN*
Posts: 2447 - Karma: 5,628
Lol, my transgender brother (formerly sister) is now with my transgender (formerly male) best friend from childhood. I couldn't be happier, it's like they're most abnormal normal couple ever.

(This is 100% a true story. They were flirting years ago. Don't think they'd been talking to each other before they both 'transitioned'. I cared then. I don't now, but that might be because I've grown up.)
10 years ago
1 1
profile picture
Toaster-Tony
Posts: 3531 - Karma: 5,850
A close friend of mine has a bangin' sister. She's pretty close in our friend group and has been known to hook up with a buddy from time to time. Her bro is cool with it and everyone is respectful. The last time it came up in conversation he just said he'd rather have her be involved with a dude he trusts and respects than the alternative. But then again it't not like he just randomly decided to run a train on his sister one day...

If it ever gets to the point where there is an unreasonable amount of tension between you and her, and if you actually value his friendship, maybe just put up the yellow light until you have a chance to talk to him about it. Sometimes you can have your cake and eat it too.
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
kim_jong_ill
Posts: 1019 - Karma: 3,147
S.J.WDon't do it dude, no good comes out of banging your friends sister.


Just really kinky threeways
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
soulskier
Posts: 17806 - Karma: 3,841
If you hook up with your bro's sister, aren't you hooking up with your sister?
10 years ago
1 0
profile picture
Spagett+
Posts: 3499 - Karma: 14,884
Mingghahahahaha this happened with my older brother and sister. My brother was pisseddddd and never talked to the dude again after he beat the shit out of him.

I feel like if you have to ask this question you realize it is at least a little wrong but I mean, you do you man haha.


ur brother sounds like a real stand up guy
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
brett_fisher
Posts: 2419 - Karma: 10,518
.lenconMy friend (who's a girl) hooked me up with her little sister who's now my gf. So I guess it's my homegirls sister. If girls are fine with it guys should be.



when your this G you don't need to know her sister #peeinherbutt
10 years ago
12 0
profile picture
ModMommy
Posts: 10877 - Karma: 58,290
A try bro asks for a blessing.
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
Krotchs_Brother
Posts: 1134 - Karma: 3,015
I don't get why people get butthurt about this kind of shit.

I would rather my best friend bang my sister (if I had one) than some nasty, random fuck.

Maybe it's because I'm European but I feel like if my boy and my sister were both down, I'd be fine with it. At least she's sucking familiar dick.




That last sentence came out way gayer than I expected but I'm gonna leave it.









;)
10 years ago
6 0
profile picture
lurking
Posts: 2227 - Karma: 6,876
Mr.noodleI once fucked my friend, it made shit kinda awkward and he couldn't sit for the next 2 days.


Pink name?
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
FastSpeed
Posts: 646 - Karma: 645
kim_jong_illI banged my buddy's twin sister so I have to say yes!


That's mad weird man (I am assuming they look similar). I couldn't bang someone who looks like my best friend. And if I could every time I looked at him I would see her.
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
kim_jong_ill
Posts: 1019 - Karma: 3,147
36ChambersOfWuThat's mad weird man (I am assuming they look similar). I couldn't bang someone who looks like my best friend. And if I could every time I looked at him I would see her.


1. They aren't that similar looking
2. he was a buddy, not my best friend
3. It was hella awkward after
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
APunx176
Posts: 1189 - Karma: 2,628
Mingghahahahaha this happened with my older brother and sister. My brother was pisseddddd and never talked to the dude again after he beat the shit out of him.

I feel like if you have to ask this question you realize it is at least a little wrong but I mean, you do you man haha.


I don't understand why people wouldn't be ok with it. One of my best friends dated my sister for a while. They broke up and it ended on really bad terms but we're still good friends
10 years ago
0 0
profile picture
GayWolf420
Posts: 38077 - Karma: 129,513
Its only rude if they dont ask you to join in. I would be greatly offended, tbqh.
10 years ago
0 0
All times are Eastern (-4); Currently it's 5:23AM