Member of the Month

Rock_Inhabitant
June, 2024

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

Opinions on overexposing snow in edits?

profile picture
Woody.
Posts: 416 - Karma: 4,623
Been seeing a lot of edits recently with really overexposed snow and it’s kinda growing on me if done right.
Aug 4 2022 4:52AM
14 0
profile picture
aldicigg
Posts: 228 - Karma: 1,396
def interested in ns's opinions as well, i kinda like it sometimes but was really weirded out when i first saw it, thought they just forgot an nd and wanted to keep the shutter long
Aug 4 2022 7:03AM
9 0
profile picture
ajbski
Posts: 1263 - Karma: 5,065
to me its not artsy at all. just someone who doesnt know how to work a camera.

but im liking stuff thats underexposed, grainy and white balance is set so the snow is grayish or creamish like bp and bdogs ensemble.
Aug 4 2022 10:54AM
21 2
profile picture
MaimHelp
Posts: 1703 - Karma: 13,449
Hate it
Aug 4 2022 12:49PM
23 1
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 61261 - Karma: 120,324
To each their own, but personally im not a fan of it, but it seems to go along with the grittiness of SD cameras and people enjoy that too.
Aug 4 2022 1:11PM
15 0
profile picture
weastcoat
Posts: 6218 - Karma: 70,835
Copycat move. Looks awful. No better way of saying hey I don’t understand How to operate a camera.
Aug 4 2022 3:11PM
19 3
profile picture
Nick_T
Posts: 71 - Karma: 471
Get an nd
Aug 4 2022 4:59PM
6 0
profile picture
Woody.
Posts: 416 - Karma: 4,623
ajbskito me its not artsy at all. just someone who doesnt know how to work a camera.

but im liking stuff thats underexposed, grainy and white balance is set so the snow is grayish or creamish like bp and bdogs ensemble.


For the most part when it’s done it’s usually on purpose and not cause of user error
Aug 4 2022 5:00PM
9 0
profile picture
BLandz
Posts: 1599 - Karma: 26,071
I know nothing about cameras so I don’t even know what u guys are talking about
Aug 4 2022 5:55PM
17 1
profile picture
andrewsmart
Posts: 273 - Karma: 2,580
It looks good if the filming and editing compliment it, or if there are coloirful rails or trees and clothing etc to contrast the snow. The problem is when people do it without knowing how or why.

Some shots in this edit use the effect really well, but only in tasteful circumstances:
https://www.newschoolers.com/videos/watch/1004675/itsnotmuch
Aug 4 2022 9:54PM
15 0
profile picture
weastcoat
Posts: 6218 - Karma: 70,835
andrewsmartIt looks good if the filming and editing compliment it, or if there are coloirful rails or trees and clothing etc to contrast the snow. The problem is when people do it without knowing how or why.

Some shots in this edit use the effect really well, but only in tasteful circumstances:
https://www.newschoolers.com/videos/watch/1004675/itsnotmuch


I totally agree this is the right amount of brightness added. You can still make out most of the snow details. I think what OP is getting at is shit so bright that you can’t even tell it’s snow, you just see a skier and rail and the brightness starts to effect the skier’s figure itself.
Aug 4 2022 10:00PM
10 0
profile picture
andrewsmart
Posts: 273 - Karma: 2,580
weastcoatI totally agree this is the right amount of brightness added. You can still make out most of the snow details. I think what OP is getting at is shit so bright that you can’t even tell it’s snow, you just see a skier and rail and the brightness starts to effect the skier’s figure itself.


Yea I meant more so at like 0:52 when he hits the sign the snows super bright, but it works really well. Any brighter for the rest of the vid would just take away.
Aug 4 2022 10:04PM
8 0
profile picture
keagan.karstens
Posts: 1510 - Karma: 32,991
Instagram filters>
Aug 5 2022 4:04AM
6 2
profile picture
rojo.grande
Posts: 1395 - Karma: 11,350
Set my wb wrong a few times and refuse to use the footage. That’s my standpoint
Aug 5 2022 11:03AM
4 0
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 61261 - Karma: 120,324
rojo.grandeSet my wb wrong a few times and refuse to use the footage. That’s my standpoint


yo, wb is the easiest thing to fix in post, hmu if you need help
Aug 5 2022 11:27AM
7 0
profile picture
rojo.grande
Posts: 1395 - Karma: 11,350
eheathyo, wb is the easiest thing to fix in post, hmu if you need help


I played w it a bit but prolly did it wrong. You familiar with resolve at all?
Aug 5 2022 12:13PM
2 0
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 61261 - Karma: 120,324
rojo.grandeI played w it a bit but prolly did it wrong. You familiar with resolve at all?


for the most part basic color correction is pretty universal but I have uses resolve. its pretty easy with skiing, you just mess around with the white point in your highlights (aka color temp) in your color wheels and just move that around until the snow is the shade of white you want. You can also do with this temp/tint sliders but its a bit more limited than using the color wheels. Im pretty sure resolve has an eye dropper for wb as well, you can select what is white in your scene and it will automatically adjust the wb.
Aug 5 2022 12:16PM
6 0
profile picture
ajbski
Posts: 1263 - Karma: 5,065
you cant fix overexposure in post... too much media loss.
Aug 5 2022 12:20PM
0 0
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 61261 - Karma: 120,324
ajbskiyou cant fix overexposure in post... too much media loss.


all depends on the camera, I've found in many cases you can save highlights to a point, but if its blown out you're fucked unless you're shootin raw

proper exposure is a tough thing in ski filming, I understand the thought/look behind overexposing because its easier to see the skier. its a balancing act most of the time
Aug 5 2022 12:36PM
4 0
profile picture
rojo.grande
Posts: 1395 - Karma: 11,350
eheathfor the most part basic color correction is pretty universal but I have uses resolve. its pretty easy with skiing, you just mess around with the white point in your highlights (aka color temp) in your color wheels and just move that around until the snow is the shade of white you want. You can also do with this temp/tint sliders but its a bit more limited than using the color wheels. Im pretty sure resolve has an eye dropper for wb as well, you can select what is white in your scene and it will automatically adjust the wb.


Sick thank you. I’ve played with tint quite a bit and didn’t get the look I wanted. Tried to resolve it a bit with a new color preset on my rig and it helped a bit. I’ve only really used the color wheels a few times but I need to start messing with them and nodes a bit more. Took a while to learn the camera and I’ve still got a ways to go but dialing in my post is next up. Thanks boss

**This post was edited on Aug 5th 2022 at 1:16:53pm
Aug 5 2022 1:16PM
1 0
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 61261 - Karma: 120,324
rojo.grandeSick thank you. I’ve played with tint quite a bit and didn’t get the look I wanted. Tried to resolve it a bit with a new color preset on my rig and it helped a bit. I’ve only really used the color wheels a few times but I need to start messing with them and nodes a bit more. Took a while to learn the camera and I’ve still got a ways to go but dialing in my post is next up. Thanks boss

**This post was edited on Aug 5th 2022 at 1:16:53pm

yeah man color shit is confusing as fuck, it took me a long time to even understand it and im still not a great colorist.

the next step is to learn how to read scopes like RGB parade, this will show you a representation of the color in your image and can be very helpful when trying to dial in your wb, contrast, etc. feel free to DM me if you have any other questions
Aug 5 2022 1:25PM
7 0
profile picture
weastcoat
Posts: 6218 - Karma: 70,835
eheathyeah man color shit is confusing as fuck, it took me a long time to even understand it and im still not a great colorist.

the next step is to learn how to read scopes like RGB parade, this will show you a representation of the color in your image and can be very helpful when trying to dial in your wb, contrast, etc. feel free to DM me if you have any other questions


Eheath a real one in this thread. I might be shooting you a message too next time I’m playing around with clips in Premiere… sometimes they come off my camera funny and I don’t understand any of the color grading shit either.
Aug 5 2022 2:48PM
7 0
profile picture
mott
Posts: 255 - Karma: 2,015
color grading is bullshit
Aug 5 2022 4:55PM
2 5
profile picture
Young_patty
Posts: 3258 - Karma: 37,292
- cool for transitions between clips.

- momentarily blinds me if I’m watching edits in the dark.
Aug 5 2022 5:22PM
5 0
profile picture
sarc
Posts: 246 - Karma: 1,879
I always figure it's unintentional.

Back when ntsc was a thing, digital brightness ran either 0-255 or something like 16-235 depending on the digital envelope / colorspace. Very pro editors used to bounce back and forth between the two unknowingly. Serious pros. The end result would have unreasonably high contrast, making white fields all the same color, like overexposed snow.

You'd see it in situations where a live broadcast looks good, but the recap would be very high contrast, because they didn't realize what was happening in the edits. National broadcast TV, used to see it all the time.

If someone's doing this as art I think it's foolish because some crotchety critic out there is going to remember history and assume it's a mistake.

Forgive me I really shouldn't drunk post.
Aug 6 2022 1:14AM
3 0
profile picture
sarc
Posts: 246 - Karma: 1,879
Let's say your edits are going from a scheme that uses the number 255 to represent full white to a scheme that uses 235 to represent full white. When converting, the software should scale the whole thing so it looks right. 255 becomes 235, 254 becomes 234.8, 253 becomes 234.6 etc.

But what they used to do is just clip it, lazy bastards. Anything above 235 is set to 235. So all the information about shading above 235 in the original scheme is gone, the white areas look overexposed because the whole area is the same brightness. Converting it back won't restore the lost information, you have to go back to source.

I think now everything is 0-255 so you don't see this, it probably is for arts sake as you say.
Aug 6 2022 11:32AM
1 0
profile picture
skiP.E.I.
Posts: 7708 - Karma: 21,046
Bad stuff. Detracts from the skiing. Overused.
Aug 6 2022 1:00PM
1 0
All times are Eastern (-4)