Twinjibber77My everyday is a Mystery Ranch 3DA and I wouldn't trade it for the world. I actually need the space, so that's never a concern.
My gym/weekend trip bag was a North Face dry duffel, but the seam ripped after 5 years of owning it and they gave me a gift card refund.
Highly considering the Project TOAD Dry Bag by Colfax Design Works although it's expesnive AF and might be a little too hardcore. I want a Mystery Ranch Saddle Peak for a touring/bc bag, but there's shit weather in my neck of the woods, so i'll wait. Without knowing anything else, I almost always reccomend something from Mystery Ranch. The 'Carryology Classified' FB group has tons of options because those dudes buy tons of bags and resell at a similar rate.
Are Mystery Ranch packs more structured? I use a peak designs pack for my EDC and I love it, but it's structured, so whether its full or not it holds the same shape. I want something that if I only have one or two things in it, it naturally compresses into a smaller bag. You know what I mean? Floppy is the wrong word, but it's the only word I can think of lol.