Member of the Month

HYP3R_REAL1TY
December, 2019

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

K2 Catamaran vs ON3P Kartel

profile picture
kazkiki7
Posts: 25
Yo yo yo guys
i currently ski on the surface daily 192 , 120 underfoot, I’m 5’11 195 so I feel like that’s an appropriate length for the future options for skis( give me input if I’m wrong)
the surface daily is great in pow and crud but a little stiff , looking for a POW slayer , Jibby ski that can still go through crud and groomers. Let me know if you guys have any preferences between the K2 and ON3P

I ski at snowbird in Utah

**This thread was edited on Dec 1st 2019 at 10:08:21pm
Dec 1 2019 9:58PM
profile picture
batskinatski
Posts: 72
Vote for the catamaran. I've skied them in powder and crud and have really enjoyed them. They are great in the air and pretty stable due to their weight. It really depends on the snow you're skiing but looking at your height and previous ski length I'd recommend the 191. Due to their extensive tip and tail rocker they ski like a much shorter ski and would feel similar in that sense to the surface daily. They are super poppy and playful and easy to butter if that is what you're interested in.
Dec 1 2019 10:03PM
profile picture
Biffbarf
Posts: 946
I own 191 catamarans and they are my fav pow ski I've ever been on. They are unsinkable and super, super playful. Some times I wish they had a little more backbone, but that's only when I'm tryna pretend I need them when it hasn't snowed in a while.

Haven't skied the kartel 116's, but if I had a guess they'd be a lil stiffer (good) but perhaps a lil less surfy due to less taper in the tips and tails. My k2's are beefy, but nothing compares to how bomber on3p's are. And, if you blow an edge out you can swap feet, on the k2 you cannot.

Don't think you can go wrong with either, but you CAN find cat's on super sale if you look and are patient if price is a factor in your decision. On3p's are $$$ but you get what you pay for.
Dec 2 2019 1:08AM
profile picture
DeebieSkeebies
Posts: 28543
Snowbird/Alta skier and Kartel 108 owner myself. Pretty killer ski if you need it to do everything. Durable as heck, solid bases, edges that hold a tune forever, great fun playful shape, and i think the flex profile is super snappy right out of the box but gets better as you ski them more. I wish I had a pair of the 116s for deeper days but ive skied plenty of deep conditions on the 108s and had a great time.

**This post was edited on Dec 2nd 2019 at 1:34:18am
Dec 2 2019 1:33AM
profile picture
.nasty
Posts: 9561
BiffbarfSome times I wish they had a little more backbone, but that's only when I'm tryna pretend I need them when it hasn't snowed in a while.


You'll be stoked on the new reckoning line next year, they make the marksman/catamaran look like poo (which they really kind of are with the lack of R&D that went into those skis haha)
Dec 2 2019 9:52AM
profile picture
kazkiki7
Posts: 25
And if i keep the dailys would the K2 make more sense as a two ski quiver?
Dec 2 2019 1:00PM
profile picture
gangsterman
Posts: 42
I own a pair of Kartel 116s and feel comfortable enough to ride them nearly everyday, no matter the conditions. Whether your choosing between a powder chuck or a one ski quiver you can't go wrong with either the Kartel/Jeffrey 116 or 108. They look sick too, the classic green bottoms are unrivaled.
Dec 3 2019 2:47PM
profile picture
f100prerunner
Posts: 270
On3p will be heavier and more durable resulting in being more chargey. K2 will be a bit less stable but lighter and jibbier. Very similar skis besides that
Dec 3 2019 5:19PM
All times are Eastern (-5)