Member of the Month

little1337
March, 2020

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

Goodbye Vimeo...

profile picture
NPF
Posts: 5146
End of an era. In the process of downloading every video i have pretty much ever made before impending doom. Vimeo is really cracking down on their copyright infringement laws. I have seen in the last week or two a few homies accounts get deleted because of copyrighted music. We are going to lose a lot of great ski edits because of it...
Oct 20 2018 5:23PM
profile picture
a_burger
Posts: 4644
quick someone who has good internet download all of the trashparty's channel
Oct 20 2018 6:41PM
profile picture
pinkcamo1000
Posts: 2054
a_burgerquick someone who has good internet download all of the trashparty's channel


this post is making me so nervous I'm checking their page like every few hours now
Oct 21 2018 2:21PM
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 54412
It was a general inevitably, you can honestly blame Vimeo for doing a shit job with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. They started off at this indie site that got too big to be "cool" anymore and they had to crack down on music or they were going to get destroyed.

Music rights in general pose a threat to all ski videos and TBH there isn't much that can be done to change it.
Oct 22 2018 10:56AM
profile picture
chris.goodhue
Posts: 922
yeah wtf alot of my videos now are gone. Don't even know where alot of the original files are....fucking blows
Oct 22 2018 1:00PM
profile picture
CLQ
Posts: 1549
eheathIt was a general inevitably, you can honestly blame Vimeo for doing a shit job with the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. They started off at this indie site that got too big to be "cool" anymore and they had to crack down on music or they were going to get destroyed.

Music rights in general pose a threat to all ski videos and TBH there isn't much that can be done to change it.


How does Newschoolers protect against it?
Oct 22 2018 2:41PM
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 54412
CLQHow does Newschoolers protect against it?


I think you're misunderstanding what I'm saying. Vimeo didn't have any sort of system to flag copyrighted music, it was a "cool" site that let people do whatever they wanted. Now they're huge and their copyright system is like YouTubes, aka if you don't have rights you're gonna get flagged, but unlike YouTube, Vimeo iust deletes videos while YouTube has many different options for people with the artists/labels.
Oct 22 2018 2:45PM
profile picture
SourSteezle
Posts: 9060
so glad I stopped using and paying for Vimeo years ago. The interface alone is awful, and the player usually sucks as well. Sad to see so many awesome edits getting deleted because Vimeo never got their shit together.
Oct 22 2018 5:52PM
profile picture
CLQ
Posts: 1549
eheathI think you're misunderstanding what I'm saying. Vimeo didn't have any sort of system to flag copyrighted music, it was a "cool" site that let people do whatever they wanted. Now they're huge and their copyright system is like YouTubes, aka if you don't have rights you're gonna get flagged, but unlike YouTube, Vimeo iust deletes videos while YouTube has many different options for people with the artists/labels.


Does NS not have to deal with these issues because this is a small site or do you do DMCA takedowns?
Oct 22 2018 6:01PM
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 54412
CLQDoes NS not have to deal with these issues because this is a small site or do you do DMCA takedowns?


If we received a dmca takedown on a video we would take it down.
Oct 22 2018 6:03PM
profile picture
chris.goodhue
Posts: 922
SourSteezleso glad I stopped using and paying for Vimeo years ago. The interface alone is awful, and the player usually sucks as well. Sad to see so many awesome edits getting deleted because Vimeo never got their shit together.


yeah really debating on stopping my subscription to Vimeo now. I'm failing to see the benefits these days
Oct 23 2018 11:02AM
profile picture
IanAvery-Leaf
Posts: 9737
chris.goodhueyeah wtf alot of my videos now are gone. Don't even know where alot of the original files are....fucking blows


recently with no warning Vimeo deleted one of my videos (so far...) and it was 9 years old without a backup, after a lot of back and forth emails saying theres nothing they can do, they finally gave me a one time use download link that expired 5 min after it was clicked haha. Good riddance Vimeo
Oct 23 2018 3:36PM
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 54412
IanAvery-Leafrecently with no warning Vimeo deleted one of my videos (so far...) and it was 9 years old without a backup, after a lot of back and forth emails saying theres nothing they can do, they finally gave me a one time use download link that expired 5 min after it was clicked haha. Good riddance Vimeo


Yeah vimeo seems to be in full panic mode
Oct 23 2018 3:39PM
profile picture
VT_scratch
Posts: 8225
IanAvery-Leafrecently with no warning Vimeo deleted one of my videos (so far...) and it was 9 years old without a backup, after a lot of back and forth emails saying theres nothing they can do, they finally gave me a one time use download link that expired 5 min after it was clicked haha. Good riddance Vimeo


Yikes... did they notify you after it was deleted at least? Or did you notice it was gone yourself?

I just emailed them asking if there's a way to batch download all 236 videos on my channel. Don't need the original file but their HQ converted version would be nice. I doubt they have a way to do this, but it would be nice to save my old ass shitty videos to look back on in the future. I went through a few of them last night from 11 years ago and they have songs by AOTP, Jedi Mind, etc. Maybe not the first videos to get pulled based on the size of those artists... but I'm sure eventually they will get to them :/
Oct 23 2018 5:44PM
profile picture
GANDALF
Posts: 6114
I set all old videos to private. Hoping my page stays alive....its also my resume....
Oct 23 2018 7:24PM
profile picture
SourSteezle
Posts: 9060
chris.goodhueyeah really debating on stopping my subscription to Vimeo now. I'm failing to see the benefits these days


damn dude! it's so wack that they do this. I lost so many of my first edits when bright cove did a similar thing years ago. Hope you get all the edits backed up before anything happens to them you got some good ones on there!
Oct 24 2018 1:17PM
profile picture
skiP.E.I.
Posts: 5174
eheathMusic rights in general pose a threat to all ski videos and TBH there isn't much that can be done to change it.


Beat making skiers on soundcloud are the answer
Oct 25 2018 3:14PM
profile picture
ChokerCatnip
Posts: 6
Damn, really?? And with Youtubes being shite as well, we're gonna need a new platform then..
Oct 27 2018 8:01AM
profile picture
Forcillo
Posts: 3803
This has been a big thing in the music video world as well. I've had homies have their work on official productions taken down in the past few weeks because they don't own licensing rights for the video they write and execute with (sometimes) their own pocket money. Say someone brings their $50k camera package on to a MV for $200 and doesn't get a DP rate because 'that was the budget.' what if that video blows up and the label makes $2,000 on the ad revenue and another $1,000 on streaming spikes? The crew gets nothing and effectively payed for some else's success. This is why unions are fantastic.

Sorry this was unrelated I'm just sad about all this
Oct 28 2018 10:39PM
profile picture
bueno
Posts: 661
ChokerCatnipDamn, really?? And with Youtubes being shite as well, we're gonna need a new platform then..

Crazy suggestion but just hear me out... newschoolers
Oct 29 2018 10:32AM
profile picture
Seagullfrien
Posts: 16
Soundcloud is a way to go. And it's easy to get a file from the platform. It's good for me as I have quite a vague web connection and having music on my phone is necessary tubeninja.net/how-to-download/mixcloud. Hope it helps.
Feb 27 2019 4:32AM
profile picture
MaxBez
Posts: 7
I started using vimeo not long ago, so I haven't noticed any issues yet. Thanks for sharing, I'll check it out!
Jul 30 2019 12:12PM
profile picture
davetron78
Posts: 531
da dum, tiss
Aug 4 2019 4:16AM
profile picture
BK
Posts: 2334
SourSteezledamn dude! it's so wack that they do this. I lost so many of my first edits when bright cove did a similar thing years ago. Hope you get all the edits backed up before anything happens to them you got some good ones on there!


This, its ironic that a VIDEO platform privileges the music rights first in theory. I could see someone making a fair use argument that when you shoot AND edit a beautiful video with music underneath it that the new work is substantially original when compared to a flat audio file. But yeah, music industry has been lawyered up so damn hard for so long, I do think music artists should be compensated, I like YouTubes approach with some music rights holders, they don't delete the video, they try to monetize the music for the artist and let the video stand as an advertisement in a sense.



That being said I only use rights cleared music now on ANYTHING I make, gotta future proof that media.
Sep 16 2019 2:57PM
All times are Eastern (-4)