Member of the Month

patagonialuke
June, 2020

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

The line between inspiration and copying edits

profile picture
Jesse_
Posts: 1496
Hear me out, I get that people can be inspired by other edits. They'll edit in a similar style and use the same type of music, whether that be by same artist or a similar one in their own edits. But they make the edit their own and usually add something new to the table. So for the most part im cool with it.

But I've seen edit where people go as far as even straight up using the exact same song and exactly copying another recent edit they like.

I feel as if their is a faint line between taking inspiration from an edit you like and blatantly copying it.

But how much do you really care? I'd like to hear your guys and girls opinion on this.

Also I apologize if this is a repost but i couldn't find anything by search barring
Oct 19 2016 11:17PM
profile picture
a_burger
Posts: 4678
Skiing is pretty difficult to copy, but it definitely bothers me if someone shoots the same trick from the same angle and slow mo's it the same way as in another edit.

I think the real big thing that bothers me though is songs, like if I see an edit with a song used in another edit and recognize it I'll immediately start comparing it to the first edit. This doesn't mean a song can be used once and never again tho, like if you think you can improve upon the first edit and do it better then go ahead, but if you can't theres not really a point.
Oct 20 2016 11:39AM
profile picture
eheath
Posts: 54862
I mean using the same song as someone else happens alot becasue people just dont watch every video, but if its done intentionally its pretty weak.

But the situation you are describing is something I have never seen outside of random kids with a gopro making edits with their friends for fun, so I don't think its actually a problem.
Oct 20 2016 12:17PM
profile picture
DominatorJacques
Posts: 4301
Jesse_Hear me out, I get that people can be inspired by other edits. They'll edit in a similar style and use the same type of music, whether that be by same artist or a similar one in their own edits. But they make the edit their own and usually add something new to the table. So for the most part im cool with it.

But I've seen edit where people go as far as even straight up using the exact same song and exactly copying another recent edit they like.

I feel as if their is a faint line between taking inspiration from an edit you like and blatantly copying it.

But how much do you really care? I'd like to hear your guys and girls opinion on this.

Also I apologize if this is a repost but i couldn't find anything by search barring


I just don't really edit at all. Just a few slo-mo's. No music at all. Are you cool with that?

https://www.newschoolers.com/videos/watch/817618/Bachelor-Parks-Real-Laps-Jonah-Elston-March-4th-2016?c=48941
Oct 20 2016 12:40PM
profile picture
KaneDog
Posts: 1481
I think the truly innovative artists understand that their own style is based on things they've been influenced by, and that it's their job to mold those ideas into a creation that becomes one that is original
Oct 20 2016 12:54PM
profile picture
Jesse_
Posts: 1496
DominatorJacquesI just don't really edit at all. Just a few slo-mo's. No music at all. Are you cool with that?

https://www.newschoolers.com/videos/watch/817618/Bachelor-Parks-Real-Laps-Jonah-Elston-March-4th-2016?c=48941


Jacques your the man, hope i can shred as awesome as you when im your age. Keep it up my dude.
Oct 20 2016 2:17PM
profile picture
Jesse_
Posts: 1496
eheathI mean using the same song as someone else happens alot becasue people just dont watch every video, but if its done intentionally its pretty weak.

But the situation you are describing is something I have never seen outside of random kids with a gopro making edits with their friends for fun, so I don't think its actually a problem.


Yeah exactly. I've just seen a shit ton of intentional "serious edits" lately where people will go out of there way to emulate edits such as simple sovereign. Which is what compelled me to make this thread.
Oct 20 2016 2:20PM
profile picture
Jesse_
Posts: 1496
Jesse_Jacques your the man, hope i can shred as awesome as you when im your age. Keep it up my dude.


Also i'm aware you arent the skier in the edit you posted (before i get called out for that). Im talking about that "Jacques the Dominator at 55 yrs. Old!" edit. That was lit.
Oct 20 2016 2:25PM
profile picture
DominatorJacques
Posts: 4301
Jesse_Also i'm aware you arent the skier in the edit you posted (before i get called out for that). Im talking about that "Jacques the Dominator at 55 yrs. Old!" edit. That was lit.


It's all good. But really, there are only so many angles and songs so after a while they all look the same.
I started doing my commentary videos because I did not want to have music copyrights on my work.
I'll still do some music from time to time for some things, but not much.
Hope you enjoy the Real Lap series. Soma do and soma don't! Can't please them all!

Hey, here is a new angle idea. Hold the camera upside-down and see how that looks.
I guess one could just flip it over with an editor too. Ha ha.

Take care Jesse
Oct 20 2016 3:32PM
profile picture
CheddarJack
Posts: 5201
I mean if they're not profiting from it, who cares?

It's like any form of art where copying is big compliment. It isn't until the copy is sold/profited from under the copier's name without acknowledgement to the original artist is there a problem. Idk how it would work exactly but I would imagine unless the edit you "copy" is sold itself/from a legit company, you wouldn't be able to get in any trouble if you were to copy and sell it.

It's like in music how you're allowed to sample songs that have royalties and sell them without issue. However, when you use a certain amount without dubbing it a remix or whatever then lawsuits happen. But if the song was never sold, the original artist would have a hard time suing.
Oct 20 2016 9:27PM
All times are Eastern (-4)