It looks like you are using an ad blocker. That's okay. Who doesn't? But without advertising revenue, we can't keep making this site awesome. Click the link below for instructions on disabling adblock.
Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post.
Register to become a member today!
Problem is, that doesn't work. When you are reading through a thread, it's very easy to read or glance at what is below it. There is no need to post SPOILER with "I will miss Ygritte. Found her so attractive" two days before the episodes airs. That ruins shit for people.
KZAProblem is, that doesn't work. When you are reading through a thread, it's very easy to read or glance at what is below it. There is no need to post SPOILER with "I will miss Ygritte. Found her so attractive" two days before the episodes airs. That ruins shit for people.
Think before you post.
I think that kind of posting is unfair to the TV show watchers. However, the spoiler button would be useful during/right after the show when people themselves have not watched the episode yet.
Additionally, it could help foster discussion about theories and such without ruining it for others.
.Hugo.Compare the book to the show in one thread, and just talk about the show in the other. How would that not work?
I am being cynical here so bear with me:
1. People would intentionally troll the show thread
2. People would start arguments in the show thread
3. People could get the threads confused
4. One thread would die out
It would take some active modding for 1-3, and just general interest for 4 to occur.
I also think the MAIN thing about this thread is that the reason it stays alive is due to the comparison. What would be talked about in the pure show thread? Speculation 24/7? Reviews?
I think the 2 threads COULD work, but I see bullet 4 being the likely outcome.
gRAPEFRUITBecause someone will always whine like a bitch.
There are plenty of message boards that are spoiler free, use those if you know this one has spoilers.
I stayed out of this thread till now because I knew there would be spoilers, so I dont care either way. I was just saying that it would work with 2 threads
.Hugo.I stayed out of this thread till now because I knew there would be spoilers, so I dont care either way. I was just saying that it would work with 2 threads
Its a sensible idea, but someone will always have a problem with it. I think a spoiler code with mods deleting anyone's post who doesn't use it would be the best option. It's not like there is a lack of mods in this thread.
If you sloptwats keep piss moaning and don't sort yourselves out, I'm gonna start naming deaths. I'll start with the end of book 5 and work my way forward.
cobra_commanderIf you sloptwats keep piss moaning and don't sort yourselves out, I'm gonna start naming deaths. I'll start with the end of book 5 and work my way forward.
There will be a new thread next year any way.
you will be IP-banned. Which is easy to get around lol. But still.
cobra_commanderIf you sloptwats keep piss moaning and don't sort yourselves out, I'm gonna start naming deaths. I'll start with the end of book 5 and work my way forward.
Barefootin_Fiendhonestly, there was already sooo much crammed into that episode, i don't see how they could have done an lsh scene and done it justice.
Considering how rushed they did every other scene I would say by either going with 11 episodes or not making episode 9 the Jon Snow show.
Barefootin_Fiendhonestly, there was already sooo much crammed into that episode, i don't see how they could have done an lsh scene and done it justice.
Do it justice? They simply could have taken out Ygritte burning, that whole scene was more than enough time to leave the cliffhanger that was LSH.
Barefootin_Fiendhonestly, there was already sooo much crammed into that episode, i don't see how they could have done an lsh scene and done it justice.
Really easily. It would have taken about 2 minutes. Brotherhood soldiers dragging some Frey captives behind them, some talk between them and prisoners about who they are and how they're going to see their leader who will decide what's done with them. "Beric Dondarrion?" No, we have a new leader now. Dragged before cloaked figure, draws back cowl revealing her face, and two raspy words: "Hang them". Scene.
and then have her fade into a distant memory since she doesn't really play any role in the story for quite some time after that one scene. there's no reason why they can't move that scene to a later episode/season other than to appease book readers.
Barefootin_Fiendand then have her fade into a distant memory since she doesn't really play any role in the story for quite some time after that one scene. there's no reason why they can't move that scene to a later episode/season other than to appease book readers.
Nah they could have her hanging Frey's for a couple ep's then mix in Brienne's story, it'll take off from there.
that sucks. her character is going to play such a huge role in the books to come. I mean Brienne bringing Jamie to her could go any which way, but I have the feeling he wouldn't be including all this in the books just as a way to kill off Jamie.
HYPE
