It just holds your skis. I'd go with anything I could afford personally. Either choice would be fine IMO so maybe just decide which one looks better or has certain features you like. Can't really go wrong with either, y'know?
"I know you believe you understand what you think I said, but I am not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant."- Alan Greenspan
Got it free with an 200$ Amazon Gift Card. One season into it, and I would have paid full price for it! Fits two pair of skis (including mi AKJJs which are 195cm), a pair of boots, two pairs of poles and any small stuff you want or clothes. If you are worried about maximum weight of luggage in airports then you should limit it to both skis, boots and poles.
Hope it helps!
This is a great bag. I would recommend getting this and a boot bag and you'll have everything you need. You can fit so much more besides skis in it, if you actually used all the space in there it would probably be too heavy. I have this one, it's great.