^Didn't you just buy the scratches and barely mount them if that? You've been asking if its a good enough ski for you since 3 weeks ago. Don't give him disinformation. Opinion is fine, but don't base that on looking at the ski in your room.
On topic, they are both great skis from what I've gleaned from reviews on here and elsewhere and the price points on each is really a top selling point. Either go by brand experience, solid reviews, try them out, or leap of faith it.