this link shows like over 40 different top 10s from a bunch of different reviews and compiled the totals.
the number 1 overall was zelda ocarina of time...
top selling ones are shown here.... wii play and wii sports are by far the best sellers (damn asains!!)
Game of year (select your personal favorite rating, I prefer Game spot or game informer)
Personally these are ones I know are worthy of top ten.
Super Smash Bros. Melee - arguably the greatest multiplayer game of all time.
Halo: Combat Evolved... the greatest FPS since ...
half life 2 ( the orange box)
Call of duty 4 : Modern Warfare
Grand theft auto III
Although I know this is completely opinionated I still like to hear what others think.