Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post.
Register to become a member today!
My first legit edit, need feedback
Posts: 1162
-
Karma: 127
alright so this is the first legit edit ive ever made, all ones prior have just been doing follow cams and not giving a shit about the shot but i decieded to get serious with this one cause i got a new cam. there is definatly some stuff i could have done better but let me know what you think
thanks,
marshall
LINK: http://www.vimeo.com/1168581
Posts: 1162
-
Karma: 127
Posts: 533
-
Karma: 72
Siiick i dig it. the filming and editing was super crisp
Posts: 3080
-
Karma: 969
yeah great job
the dolly shots were really sick just subtle it was nice
and yeah editing was super crisp it all went well
enjoyed watching sick job.
what cam did you get?
Posts: 2333
-
Karma: 246
not bad. especially for first edit.
i would seriously try to change up your shots. The one dolly angle at the side of the box got really really repetitive.
Also with your pans, try to get them a lil' smoother.
and try to get the tracks from your dolly outta the shot, it ruins the effect.
what did you use for it anyway? cause it slides on snow. Your smart.
Posts: 2333
-
Karma: 246
and use dolly shots in moderation. Every shot being a dolly shot makes it not special anymore.
Posts: 11052
-
Karma: 113
Excessive overuse of that dolly/moving shot...
What did you film it with? Looks like a HV20-esque picture, on a sunny day.
Posts: 12808
-
Karma: 1,945
Posts: 354
-
Karma: 78
nicee! sick edit man. did i catch a glimpse of the 08/09 walls or was that just my imagination?
Posts: 4350
-
Karma: 1,111
the only thing that really came to my mind was you need more definition between the skier the sky and the snow. just saturating your colors abit should do this.
Posts: 2100
-
Karma: 23
x2
also too many cross fades. Dont be afraid of hard cuts
Very good job over all though. I find it a little hard to believe it's your first edit.
Posts: 4684
-
Karma: 114
Posts: 1162
-
Karma: 127
thanks for all the feedback guys, i really appreciate it
Posts: 6974
-
Karma: 79
I found that the skiers were hard to see. Mess with the color levels, brightness, saturation, etc to get more contrast. And I agree that the dissolves were overused.
Posts: 316
-
Karma: 16
you stole my last name. haha jk that was pretty sick.
Posts: 2028
-
Karma: 174
that was a nice edit, but it got boring, too much rails.
what cam u use? what kinda dolly?
Posts: 1152
-
Karma: 13
nice editing and sick filming but i think you should have more variation. there were just too many shots on like the flat down flat box or whatever it was
Posts: 2261
-
Karma: 71
sweet edit!
just try to get the dolly shots a tad bit smoother cos all of them stopped suddenly right before the clip ended and it got a little annoying
what camera and dolly did you use?
Posts: 5786
-
Karma: 4,457
like what i'm hearin for sure
Posts: 15949
-
Karma: 9,432
really sick. i especially like the shot of the c box around 1:00
Posts: 15967
-
Karma: 11,016
aight, just a suggestion---u coulda tried to edit on the beats a little more
also yeah u've heard it--overused dolly/dissolves
liked the song, dope skiing
Posts: 5313
-
Karma: 356
mentioned before but Ill repeat. You need to get the dolly tracks out of there.. I have always been told to never shoot/film your own equipment. Also, IMO I hate when you can see the camera mans shadow. Im not sure why but it just seems lame. Also with your dollys slow it down a bit on some like make it more smooth, and make sure you start moving before your filming or atleast be smoother with starting your dolly..
Posts: 2538
-
Karma: 26
Posts: 3757
-
Karma: 44
well done, i like the panning action, although there was a lot of it.
1000th post hurrah!
Posts: 21061
-
Karma: 8,366
Was that a Jon Sexauer I saw in there?
Posts: 2503
-
Karma: 779
quality, use of shots and editing was overall good, but i the dolly shot and the crossfades were really repetitive
Posts: 403
-
Karma: 35
Posts: 1133
-
Karma: 13
That was a pretty sick edit, but you over used the dolly, crossfades, and same rails. Not that I don't like rails, but there were too many shots of the same rail all in a row. If you can, try to get the riders to connect two features in one run, just hitting one feature gets a little old. Try messing with follow cams too, I like follow cams.
Posts: 99
-
Karma: 10
real sick, i just got kinda bored with all the same shit
All times are Eastern (-4)
