I got Valo TV.2 Limited blue ones when they had them, I wear a 9 in shoes, but I got 10 in Valo's. My feet are average width. Though I wish I got a 9 so they would be tighter on my feet. I would say get the 10's if your feet are really 9.5 though I don't know how wide your foot really is. On a side note I find Valos very comfy and my toes feel greg, good padding around the toes, but not excessive. I like the simplicity of there skates and style.