Overall great. Not perfect but I'd recommend them to pretty much anyone. They keep your legs warm but not the most breathable fabric. Insulation is a huge bummer when it comes to breathability. They are mildly waterproof but laughable compared to the shell pants I have now. At 5'9 the size large was quite baggy.
The newsprint version is a sick fabric design and it keeps someone like me entertained on long charlift rides forever.