Welcome to our new beta design! Click here to go back to the old Newschoolers.
CyanicenineSidecut definitely deserves to be on there. I think it may have moved to priority number one for me. After that it would be; Length > Shape > Flex > Construction (sidewall please, no cap) > Base Material > Weight > Graphics.
You need to have the right mix of all of these, but certain things definitely take priority.