Welcome to our new beta design! Click here to go back to the old Newschoolers.
DINKLEBERGHate to give you the classic "go see a bootfitter, man.", but that can be a lot more helpful than "just get Full Tilts." Most of FT's boots are 99mm and I've heard of lots of complaints from people with narrower feet about them being too constrictive.
Also, don't rely on just two brands for comparison. Go try a bunch of different brands/models on and get the pair that truly fits you. Don't let the image of a brand sway your opinion.
Good luck OP.