can't say much about the tahoe, but the Caylor is gonna be a lot stiffer than the benchetler. both are pretty similar skis, but the chets will be softer. I ride 191 Caylors and I can't say enough good things about them. They really are bombproof skis, and i have put them through everything; from sliding sideways across rocks, to landing on rocks, to even losing one in february and finding it this month (only thing wrong was rusty edges).
if you want a more all mountain ski that can still handle some pow, check out the Jeffrey. it's not as wide underfoot as the caylor but is a similar type of ski.
so basically, the Caylor will do everything that the Benchetler will do, but if you'd like a softer ski go with the Benchetlers. keep in mind that supporting a smaller brand is a great thing as well and you will find their skis are higher quality!