Timex Weekender. Choose your favorite color band.
Simple, low profile, tons of canvas band choices, easy to read, Indiglo. I think it's your ticket.
For a fairly cheap watch, I prefer to stay away from leather bands. Rarely do I see cheap leather that looks good.
Despite having several more expensive watches, I wear this all the time:
I like the extremely understated aesthetics and low profile. It has a plastic band though. I like it because I can sweat and just wipe it off. I bought my first one before traveling to Nicaragua then liked it so much (and its so cheap) that I have several more.