Hmm JD, interesting point as always, but I beg to differ with the statement 'they're deriving a moral policy from the church, they're uninformed with regard to ethical theory'
Ethics and religion have ALWAYS gone hand in hand throughout history, because religion has always been the basis for a moral code. In Islamic countries, their morals are based on the Quaran. In Isreal, is the Torah that provides the code of ethics many Jews live by.
Here in North America, our moral code is based on the Bible, like it or not. The Ten Commandments have always been the cornerstone of any code of ethics. People say they don't belive in religion, they 'just know' what is right and what is wrong. But that knowlege comes from a society that is based on traditional, Christian values. Why do we believe its wrong to steal? Because our ancestors taught their kids, 'Thou shalt not steal. In some cultures stealing is not forbidden, it is actually rewarded if the thief is succesful.
This brings me to my point: the problem with modern ethical theory. If I understand it correctly, it states that there is no concrete right or wrong, but that everyone must make up his or her own moral code based on what 'feels right'. This WILL NOT work towards a succesful society! This is like taking the rudder off a ship and giving every sailor a piece of string and telling them to steer the ship in whatever direction they think is best! This leads to chaos, a lack of direction for society, and in my opinion, is responsible for much of the divorce, teenage crime,and problems in North America. People do what 'feels right' but often this is very wrong.
How does this theory that 'truth is relative' work? What is to stop me from creating a moral code that suits me, but is not in the best intrests of others, or of society? Look at the 9/11 bombers, or people who blow up abortion clinics. They are convinced that they are doing the right thing, in their 'code of ethics' murder is justified. If I throw out the traditional code of ethics, why do I have to be faithful to my girlfriend/wife? Why do I have to pay taxes? Why can't I steal my neighbors car if he has three and I don't have a car at all?
This is why I support a traditional code of ethics. America is founded on Christian values, despite the faults, it has made American the most powerful country in the world. Why mess with a good thing, and throw out the old code of ethics until you see if the new one will work?
WE TAKE THESE RISKS NOT TO ESCAPE LIFE, BUT SO THAT LIFE DOES NOT ESCAPE US