Greatest drummer

Posts: 2255 - Karma: 30

Karma: 30

Posts: 2255

Addict

carter is definitely good, but i think the top would be john bonham and buddy rich
___________________

www.ohiofreestyle.com

Sep 13 2004 12:37PM

0 0

DAMICO

Posts: 2645 - Karma: 12

Karma: 12

Posts: 2645

Addict

i like bonham from led zepp......

**********************************************************************

My Hardy Boys are killing me... it's no mystery!

*NS Skateboarders Cult*

Sep 13 2004 1:42PM

0 0

hkmk

Posts: 45 - Karma: 10

Karma: 10

Posts: 45

Lame

carter's ok.... but it's really all about neil peart. the guys insane.

For Those About To Rock,,,, We Salute You!!!! - AC/DC

Sep 13 2004 3:38PM

0 0

Posts: 10928 - Karma: 36

Karma: 36

Posts: 10928

Crazy Fool

bonham and carter for sure. I used to really like peart, but he looks too pissed off when he plays, ruins the mood of the song.

Sep 13 2004 4:23PM

0 0

weazelzb

Posts: 4454 - Karma: 12

Karma: 12

Posts: 4454

No Life

bonham and keith moon

Some folks look for answers, others look for fights
Some folks up in tree tops, just looking for their kites

Goes to show, you don't ever know
Watch each card you play and play it slow

Sep 13 2004 5:01PM

0 0

Joe.

Posts: 2888 - Karma: 24

Karma: 24

Posts: 2888

Addict

i love how when you see carter playing a concert...he always has bubble gum in his mouth and when they zoom in on him and hes just rocking out he'll blow a bubble...yeah i still think hes hte best drummer....he really is the heart behind dave matthews

my mom plucks my ball hair at night when im sleeping and glues them to her eyesbrows cuz she had a terrible camping incident when she was younger and her eyebrows never grew back, shes been doing this since i was 13 im gonna have to start chargin that fat bitch for my hair
-lateralis

Sep 13 2004 5:06PM

0 0

Posts: 8681 - Karma: 54

Karma: 54

Posts: 8681

Crazy Fool

i'll second keith moon

-Lauren

Lauren and Ella: together changing teenaged boys lives since 2001.

THE FIST OF FURY
Fistin' Mad Bitches!

This is one voice not to forget:
'Fight every fight like you can win;
An iron-fisted champion,
An iron-willed fuck up.'

Skiing's not a sport, it's a lifestyle.

Sep 13 2004 5:18PM

0 0

joey_fauth

Posts: 318 - Karma: 27

Karma: 27

Posts: 318

Loner

dan trapp, josh freese
peep

Sep 13 2004 5:36PM

0 0

Dr.Dealgood

Posts: 2587 - Karma: 1,352

Karma: 1,352

Posts: 2587

Addict

John Fishman anyone?
-AndrewP
----------------------

Per solitudinem ardere in remedium formidinis dictitabat.

Define to me a waste of space.

Sep 13 2004 7:39PM

0 0

Posts: 10928 - Karma: 36

Karma: 36

Posts: 10928

Crazy Fool

hah, Keith Moon or his clone in the Interior. Either one.

Sep 13 2004 8:03PM

0 0

Posts: 8681 - Karma: 54

Karma: 54

Posts: 8681

Crazy Fool

^haha yes sam!!! jamie! that kid is INSANE!

-Lauren

Lauren and Ella: together changing teenaged boys lives since 2001.

THE FIST OF FURY
Fistin' Mad Bitches!

This is one voice not to forget:
'Fight every fight like you can win;
An iron-fisted champion,
An iron-willed fuck up.'

Skiing's not a sport, it's a lifestyle.

Sep 13 2004 8:24PM

0 0

IWD

Posts: 88 - Karma: 10

Karma: 10

Posts: 88

Wannabe

Neil Pert. Insane drummer, listen to any of his solos or any Rush song. You will see.

514

Sep 13 2004 9:27PM

0 0

Posts: 8681 - Karma: 54

Karma: 54

Posts: 8681

Crazy Fool

yeah man... the guy from RUSH has an INTENSE set.

-Lauren

Lauren and Ella: together changing teenaged boys lives since 2001.

THE FIST OF FURY
Fistin' Mad Bitches!

This is one voice not to forget:
'Fight every fight like you can win;
An iron-fisted champion,
An iron-willed fuck up.'

Skiing's not a sport, it's a lifestyle.

Sep 13 2004 9:28PM

0 0

Posts: 10928 - Karma: 36

Karma: 36

Posts: 10928

Crazy Fool

he's got an intense set for sure. But I find him kind of boring. His dvd put me to sleep and his style is too choppy for me. But shit, he's damn good, just again, he always looks mad while playing.

Sep 13 2004 10:02PM

0 0

the_friesz

Posts: 1007 - Karma: 18

Karma: 18

Posts: 1007

Insane

Fuck them all, Rick Allen from Def Lepp, the man has talent... And one arm...

'...Smoking's bad, smoking killed my dad. Yeah, he was driving down the highway one day and as he was lighting his cigarette, it blew out the window. So he jumps out the door to save it, and ran himself over. Uh, you mind if I smoke?' -Olie Ollaussen, Ski Bum extraordinaire

Sep 14 2004 3:06AM

0 0

Posts: 3328 - Karma: 11

Karma: 11

Posts: 3328

Addict

you guys are silly. have you even heard any jaz? the shit those guys do with a drum kit is completely insaine. other than that, grindcore has to take the cake for the best drummers. i'd have to say that the drummer from Ion Dissonance has to be up there with the best.

Dave Pauls
www.NSClothing.com
www.CorbettsSkiShop.com

I like dead kittens.

Sep 14 2004 12:44PM

0 0

SohCahToa

Posts: 1221 - Karma: 11

Karma: 11

Posts: 1221

Insane

josh freese for today. i just listened to a vandals album i had lost for a long time....not the best tech stuff, but it works with the music and is fun to listen to. also, check the fuck out of Dan/jeff from small brown bike

Sep 14 2004 5:43PM

0 0

Jrich23

Posts: 481 - Karma: 10

Karma: 10

Posts: 481

Ridiculous

Stephen Morris from Joy Division

Sep 14 2004 6:03PM

0 0

selfportrait

Posts: 1632 - Karma: 16

Karma: 16

Posts: 1632

Insane

Aaron Cometbus. No contest

no. he's not the best, but he's ben in some very good bands.

.CCR.
impact

Sep 14 2004 6:31PM

0 0

Mad_Trix540

Posts: 790 - Karma: 10

Karma: 10

Posts: 790

Ridiculous

neil pert from rush, keith moon from the who, best of all: Bonzo from zeppelin

jeff

Sep 14 2004 6:37PM

0 0

CTripper

Posts: 6520 - Karma: 20

Karma: 20

Posts: 6520

No Life

billy martin billy martin billy martin
-chris

Sep 14 2004 6:59PM

0 0

Posts: 10928 - Karma: 36

Karma: 36

Posts: 10928

Crazy Fool

Steve Smith and elvin fucking jones.

Sep 14 2004 7:45PM

0 0

Posts: 10928 - Karma: 36

Karma: 36

Posts: 10928

Crazy Fool

stanton Moore. Wow, i can't make up my mind.

Sep 14 2004 9:10PM

0 0

RandomHero21

Posts: 1335 - Karma: 15

Karma: 15

Posts: 1335

Insane

Fuck......I can not even believe I forgot about Billy Martin....he is out of this world. And can't forget about Zach Velmer from Sector 9. He can keep the sickest beats going at breakneck speed forever.

I don't know karate, but I know Ka-razy

Sep 15 2004 12:59AM

0 0

Posts: 2255 - Karma: 30

Karma: 30

Posts: 2255

Addict

i think from current day drummers Travis Barker is on top..before you anyone says 'fuck blink', 'those guys are pussies' or anything else half retarded, listen to the shit he's done with the transplants, black eyed peas, boxcar racer, blink, the list goes on..
___________________

www.ohiofreestyle.com

Sep 15 2004 8:11AM

0 0

Schoening

Posts: 14332 - Karma: 1,266

Karma: 1,266

Posts: 14332

Crazy Fool

Buddy Rich

sms sess 4

Sep 15 2004 8:17AM

0 0

Posts: 3328 - Karma: 11

Karma: 11

Posts: 3328

Addict

Travis Barker or what ever his name is sucks ass. i don't think any of you have actually heard good drumming. there are no phenominal drummers in punk. The genre just isn't chalanging. sure they are fast... but they don't have to be good to be fast. I had this explained to me one like this... drumming punk is like hucking an upright penciled out 1080. it is hard to do, and it is fast, but it will never be as good as a super smooth corked 540. drumming is more about style and getting the time chainges and switching up the beat and shit. its a lot more technical than just taking the simple beats and making them faster. jaz is the king of that shit... just tossing in weird assed shit that you are like 'what the fuck are they doing?' then you get hardcore or grind music where you get a lot of jaz drummers that are bored with jaz playing rediculously technical music REALLY fast. they are like tossing a switch corked 1080 with an inside out grab from the second you leave the jump to the time your skis touch the ground. tough to do, fast, but still looks real good. that is why i think that grind bands have the best drummers.... oh and they do it completely for the love of the music.... cuz really good drumming is hard to listen to. its not some crazy sellout shit. oh yea and just because you have a lot of drums doesn't mean you are good. and thats my rant.

Dave Pauls
www.NSClothing.com
www.CorbettsSkiShop.com

I like dead kittens.

Sep 15 2004 9:29AM

0 0

Posts: 3328 - Karma: 11

Karma: 11

Posts: 3328

Addict

Travis Barker or what ever his name is sucks ass. i don't think any of you have actually heard good drumming. there are no phenominal drummers in punk. The genre just isn't chalanging. sure they are fast... but they don't have to be good to be fast. I had this explained to me one like this... drumming punk is like hucking an upright penciled out 1080. it is hard to do, and it is fast, but it will never be as good as a super smooth corked 540. drumming is more about style and getting the time chainges and switching up the beat and shit. its a lot more technical than just taking the simple beats and making them faster. jaz is the king of that shit... just tossing in weird assed shit that you are like 'what the fuck are they doing?' then you get hardcore or grind music where you get a lot of jaz drummers that are bored with jaz playing rediculously technical music REALLY fast. they are like tossing a switch corked 1080 with an inside out grab from the second you leave the jump to the time your skis touch the ground. tough to do, fast, but still looks real good. that is why i think that grind bands have the best drummers.... oh and they do it completely for the love of the music.... cuz really good drumming is hard to listen to. its not some crazy sellout shit. oh yea and just because you have a lot of drums doesn't mean you are good. and thats my rant.

Dave Pauls
www.NSClothing.com
www.CorbettsSkiShop.com

I like dead kittens.

Sep 15 2004 9:30AM

0 0

Posts: 2255 - Karma: 30

Karma: 30

Posts: 2255

Addict

haha dude obviously you're basing your judgement solely on a couple blink-182 songs and not much else...i've played drums/percussion for the past 13 years, so i think i have a little more knowledge about this subject than alot of people who're just basing their opinions sheerly on what they hear rather than what they know...travis' playing with blink-182 is only about 1/10th of what he can do...i know this through seeing him play with multiple other groups, artists, and students...i have also spoken to some of his students, one of them being 16-17 yr. old phenom by the name of Ilan Rubin, drummer for F.O.N. and Denver Harbor, who has even told me what people see him do with blink is only a small small piece of what he can actually do...and the 'crazy random stuff' you talk about in his playing with blink-182 is actually called latin drumming...just because it doesn't have a 2 and 4 feel to it doesn't mean its 'crazy random stuff', its probably the hardest style to play along with jazz ecspecially while trying to put it into a punk song...slayer asked travis to drum for them but he turned them down...that's probably not the sign of a shitty drummer, if you've ever heard slayer's drumming before...also, he plays with countless other artists such as Tim Armstrong from Rancid, and the Transplants, as well as Black Eyed Peas and his solo stuff with Will.I.Am, he's played with Pink (shes lame but its still credible), as well as others...i agree alot of punk drumming is redundant fast 2 and 4 and not much more, however Travis Barker has set himself apart from that...being voted best drummer of the year 2 years in a row has to have some kind of credibility to it dont you think?
___________________

www.ohiofreestyle.com

Sep 15 2004 10:01AM

0 0

CTripper

Posts: 6520 - Karma: 20

Karma: 20

Posts: 6520

No Life

i hate drummers with a lot of drums. THE ILLEST CATS OUT THERE PLAY JAZZ. i don't care if you disagree. jazz players can hold it down on simple sets. it's not what you play, it's how you play it. please for the love of god someone download live MEDESKI MARTIN AND WOOD.
-chris

Sep 15 2004 1:39PM

0 0

Posts: 8681 - Karma: 54

Karma: 54

Posts: 8681

Crazy Fool

SIDIKKI SIOUZ! none of you know him. well maybe like 1 or 2 people on this site do. he teaches doundon and djembe classes in vermont, he is fucking INSANE. on the djembe that is.

-Lauren

Lauren and Ella: together changing teenaged boys lives since 2001.

THE FIST OF FURY
Fistin' Mad Bitches!

This is one voice not to forget:
'Fight every fight like you can win;
An iron-fisted champion,
An iron-willed fuck up.'

Skiing's not a sport, it's a lifestyle.

Sep 15 2004 2:22PM

0 0

wazzucrewskier

Posts: 2269 - Karma: 151

Karma: 151

Posts: 2269

Addict

DANNY CARREY (from tool) holy crap he has a freakin 25 piece set, and has the fastest hands ever. plus in every song he has the most creative/ crazy solos. just download jerk off, or pushit and you will soon bow down to his highness.

'If she floats than she is not
A witch like we had thought'
'Like most babies smell like butter
his smell smelled like no other'
'She'll come back as fire, to burn all the liars,
And leave a blanket of ash on the ground.' - Kurt Cobain

Sep 15 2004 9:22PM

0 0

Hepcat1000000000

Posts: 319 - Karma: 10

Karma: 10

Posts: 319

Loner

Jonathon Mover, Virgil Donati, although he's not the best by far I love Chad Sexton from 311, and even Travis Barker's work with the aquabats should be at least a slight reminder that he can playing stuff besides fast punk. I remember when I was little I used to think the guy from Sum 41 was an awesome drummer...my how things have changed. What's who the German dude with that extreme interdependance book? My drum teacher was explaining some of the stuff he did on one of his videos or something, and I could barely keep my mouth closed...
***********************
FIGHT FOR YOUR RIGHT TO SKANK!

Emo kids don't cry because they're sad all the time, they cry because they have to listen to that horrible music all the time. I'd cry if i had to listen to that whiny music over and over and over....wouldn't you?

(I'm in a band, go to purevolume.com and check out East Coast Skank. Our recording sucks, but bear with it...)

Sep 15 2004 10:36PM

0 0

Schoening

Posts: 14332 - Karma: 1,266

Karma: 1,266

Posts: 14332

Crazy Fool

ok the guy from The Who wins being the craziest drummer

sms sess 4

Sep 16 2004 8:14AM

0 0

tratank

Posts: 167 - Karma: 89

Karma: 89

Posts: 167

Pro

grohl, when him and hawkins ahv a drum off, which they often do it seriously kicks off!

www.negativegravity.co.uk

Sep 16 2004 8:46AM

0 0

Posts: 3328 - Karma: 11

Karma: 11

Posts: 3328

Addict

pop pop pop

Dave Pauls
www.NSClothing.com
www.CorbettsSkiShop.com

I like dead kittens.

Sep 16 2004 9:22AM

0 0

Posts: 2255 - Karma: 30

Karma: 30

Posts: 2255

Addict

ductapeboy you didn't have much to say about my travis barker post
___________________

www.ohiofreestyle.com

Sep 16 2004 10:07AM

0 0

Posts: 10928 - Karma: 36

Karma: 36

Posts: 10928

Crazy Fool

extreme interdepence was written by Marco Minneman. He's great but it kills me how he never holds a groove.

Sep 16 2004 10:15AM

0 0