Hestra is so far above and beyond any other glove company it's not even fair. The only thing that keeps every single person from owning them is the price, but they're definitely worth it, they're just outside the realm of affordable for a lot of people. if price isn't an issue, get Hestra for sure. The 3 finger Seth gloves are my personal fav. I'm absolutely obsessed with mine.
i have the seth morrison 3 finger pro model from hestra. ive never put my hands in anything warmer, not to mention the glvoes have a bit a padding. i know you dont want mittens, but the 3 finger is awesome. but im pretty sure hestra has a 5 finger model of the morrison pros. you will not be dissapointed with these