Member of the Month

PartyBullshiit
March, 2024

Online

Welcome to the Newschoolers forums! You may read the forums as a guest, however you must be a registered member to post. Register to become a member today!

If money wasn't a factor...

profile picture
MaryJane
Posts: 193 - Karma: 10
Everyone seems to agree that if you own a PC, Adobe Premier is the program to use when video editing...and if you own a Mac, it's Final Cut.

I know those are the two best rated video editing programs for their respective platforms....but between the two, which is better.

The next computer I get is going to be geared 100% for video editing and possibly 3D animation; between a PC (adobe premier) and a Mac (Final Cut) which tends to be better for this aspect?

I would especially like to hear from those who have used both. Do you find one better than the other? Why?

I've read reviews in different computer magazines and websites, but none of what I've found compairs the PC to a Mac....they all just compair PC programs to themselves, and Mac Programs to themselves.

Anyway, just looking for user opinions....and yes I've done a forum search and haven't found the info I've been looking for.


---------------

'It's the homeboy shopping network. We got car stereos, we got car alarms, and if you act now...we could probably get the car!'
Dec 4 2003 11:21AM
0 0
profile picture
yeti
Posts: 6335 - Karma: 17
Final Cut with After Effects. Step up to the plate little boy.

*******************
'yeti you're my new hero' - lineskier10

'the more it hurts, the better it feels' - Sarah

'i always make my bitches get abortions' - Dave Pauls
FROSTMONKEY
Dec 4 2003 11:31AM
0 0
profile picture
Lord_Piot
Posts: 3727 - Karma: 13
Final cut is decidedly better then premier...So if you want a 100% video editing machine then i guess a mac is better. But if you want 3D animation and want to use programs like maya or brice3d then you are going to need a PC platform.
_________________
Personaly I believe my short term memory has been affected but that is the main side effect and I also think maybe my short term memory has been affected.

Pimpin since Pimpin be Pimpin been Pimpin - Dedicated to Mr Caylor.
Dec 4 2003 1:49PM
0 0
profile picture
hexum
Posts: 840 - Karma: 10
go with the pc, you can actually upgrade it

If you have a 1380 SAT and a 86.71 GPA... what does everyone say? Not good job, not 'O wow, thats awesome!' No, they say things like 'You are an underachiever'

Originally posted by strode420
'it was impressive, sort of like a gay dude taking a cock that's too big for him without screaming'
Dec 4 2003 4:20PM
0 0
profile picture
c_lo
Posts: 1281 - Karma: 10
Fizzinal cut, what

Dec 4 2003 4:52PM
0 0
profile picture
yeti
Posts: 6335 - Karma: 17
'you can actually upgrade it'

yeah you're right, you can't throw a larger hard drive, more ram or a new video card in a mac.

you sir are a fucking retard. dont talk out of your ass.

*******************
'yeti you're my new hero' - lineskier10

'the more it hurts, the better it feels' - Sarah

'i always make my bitches get abortions' - Dave Pauls
FROSTMONKEY
Dec 4 2003 7:49PM
0 0
profile picture
Itsbackfliptime
Posts: 18901 - Karma: 75
I have very limited use with them but I've used both. I liked the layout of Final Cut better and it was a little easier for what I did.

Coming Soon...
Dec 4 2003 8:07PM
0 0
profile picture
What_A_Wookie
Posts: 3231 - Karma: 21
your going to want to go mac on this one
_________________________
And for America, there will be no going back to the era before September the 11th, 2001 — to false comfort in a dangerous world. We have learned that terrorist attacks are not caused by the use of strength; they are invited by the perception of weakness. And the surest way to avoid attacks on our own people is to engage the enemy where he lives and plans. We are fighting that enemy in Iraq and Afghanistan today so that we do not meet him again on our own streets, in our own cities. - George W. Bush

Dec 5 2003 7:49PM
0 0
profile picture
linejibber550
Posts: 2400 - Karma: 2
definetly mac, ive used both. i havent used final cut pro but everyone says its better and rins alor faster. and as far as 3d goes every 3D program except 3Dsmax is on mac. for 3d go with lightwave or maya, i think lightwave is better out of the 2 but its up to u. there tons more 3d programs but those are the only 2 ive tried. im buying lightwave for my mac when version 8 comes out
Dec 5 2003 8:15PM
0 0
profile picture
RideBLUNT
Posts: 3393 - Karma: 11
DEFINETELY A MAC!!


Rock that shit
Dec 5 2003 11:18PM
0 0
profile picture
TAK
Posts: 5007 - Karma: 14
Uh... Mac.
----------------------------------------

~~Phunkin Phatt Phreerider~~
Dec 6 2003 8:02PM
0 0
profile picture
ThisAngelicRage
Posts: 8681 - Karma: 54
I really am not a big Mac fan but I like Final Cut Pro a lot more. It's so easy to use. In general, Mac's are a lot better for kind of video editing and entertainment purposes.





-Lauren


I'm not much of a man by the light of day
But by night I'm one hell of a lover
I'm just a sweet transvestite
From Transexual Transylvania...
Dec 6 2003 10:37PM
0 0
profile picture
therealjerk
Posts: 2806 - Karma: 26
Final Cut, hands down.

'This one goes out to all the depressed women in the house.
Whether you taken the Prozac, the Zanax, or the Pax, or whatever the hell they put in the caps.
I want y'all to come up to the front of the stage, grab me a shot of something along the way.
Put a smile on the front of your head.'
Dec 7 2003 12:52AM
0 0
profile picture
3ski6guy0
Posts: 9201 - Karma: 132
i would get a pc because if u want animation too its good, bryce is a kick ass program
********* ********* *********
LAND SHARK!!! EEEEE EEEEEE EEEEEEE
Dec 7 2003 1:16AM
0 0
profile picture
B-Wald
Posts: 8113 - Karma: 96
if yer goin for editing..and editing only..then definitely go with final cut/mac..

there's more choices for 3d graphics and such for windows..but there is maya for mac..

and for this..leave all the os and hardware arguments outta this..they dont' have anything to do with what he's asking..

------------------------

- Andrew Berwald
Dec 7 2003 2:52PM
0 0
profile picture
h3ofilms
Posts: 4214 - Karma: 12
untrue, heres the scoop

get the mac...Final Cut Pro is hands down better then Premier. Plus with a mac, u can have Premier as well on the computer. You get both programs under one platform (pc will NEVER see FCP like the pope will never see pussy)

3d rendering, Maya is hands down the best program. Maya also comes under the Mac platform. As well ad 3dmax, and Maxon4d.

trust me, macs are more reliable, better build (my g5 case has insane construction inside and out, pictures dont do it justice), and has all the programs you want

dual processors, 8 gig max ram, wonderful design, all the programs, professional proven skills. Get the mac

Line Skis
Siver Cartel
Orage
Powder
Armada
Dynastar
Dec 7 2003 8:10PM
0 0
profile picture
B-Wald
Posts: 8113 - Karma: 96
'untrue, heres the scoop'..wha?
------------------------

- Andrew Berwald
Dec 7 2003 8:48PM
0 0
profile picture
skodeo7
Posts: 14949 - Karma: 9,234
FCP is damn nice. That does not mean that you cannot do a very solid job with a good pc and premiere.
|D|U|N|C|A|N|
Junction 133 Productions
Rural Uproar Teaser
SRMC
Dec 7 2003 8:53PM
0 0
profile picture
MaryJane
Posts: 193 - Karma: 10
Well, it's mainly going to be for video editing. My bro just got a real power house PC and I can install the copy of lightwave I have on that computer. I haven't really gotten into the 3D stuff yet, but will soon.

So yeah, this would be primarily for video editing.


---------------

'It's the homeboy shopping network. We got car stereos, we got car alarms, and if you act now...we could probably get the car!'
Dec 8 2003 12:06AM
0 0
profile picture
hype
Posts: 1440 - Karma: 21
priemerem is betta
Dec 8 2003 10:40AM
0 0
profile picture
nipe
Posts: 2586 - Karma: 6
nice, another G5 user.

Do yourself a favor and buy a Mac. You will thanks us all mulitible times later on.
______________
seth

Fairygirl: Why must you be so damn good looking? Why?? lol
nipe: Thats right Diabhal, because we're skiers
Dec 8 2003 11:29AM
0 0
profile picture
MaryJane
Posts: 193 - Karma: 10
nipe..and all other Mac users...

The only problem is, I don't have the money for a G5 at the moment. (although I wasn't planning on making a purchase for a while anyway.)

That being said, I am a Mac virgin. I've never owned one, and (other than the various iMac email stations around campus) I've never really used one. Are they difficult to upgrade? Is it possible to bring files from my PC to the Mac? What kind of support is there for 'tech-intelegent' first time Mac users? ect...

I mean, I know nothing about Mac's. I know a lot about PC maintenance and upkeep, but nothing regarding Mac. Do they go obcelete(sp?) as quickly as PC's?

Thanks for the info so far, I really appreciate it.



---------------

'It's the homeboy shopping network. We got car stereos, we got car alarms, and if you act now...we could probably get the car!'
Dec 8 2003 12:40PM
0 0
profile picture
cheetojackson
Posts: 56 - Karma: 10
They push for people to use macs for video producion but I dont think it really matters. I think you can multi-task so much better on a pc compared to a Mac. I goto the art instuiute chicago and they teach us both and i think it just comes down to with whatever one you like better...You can upgrade macs just fine...the parts are fucking spendy as fuck though....and macs can read PC files....I would get a PC though ...if you are going to be doing 3d modeling and 3d design shit I think PCs are way better for that
Dec 8 2003 1:39PM
0 0
All times are Eastern (-4)